We're closing the office on Tuesday to give the team a hard earned break.
Any orders placed on Mon 27 will ship on Wed 29.
We're buying all these cards, and more! Instructions on how to sell to us can be found here.
25% Bonus for Store Credit!
MTG MATE - Hot List
Den of the Bugbear
Adventures in the Forgotten Realms
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Guardian of Faith
Adventures in the Forgotten Realms
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 15
Lair of the Hydra
Adventures in the Forgotten Realms
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Paladin Class
Adventures in the Forgotten Realms
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 15
Teleportation Circle
Adventures in the Forgotten Realms
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Werewolf Pack Leader
Adventures in the Forgotten Realms
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 15
Fellwar Stone
Forgotten Realms Commander
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Endurance
Modern Horizons 2
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 15
Scalding Tarn
Modern Horizons 2
Cash: $30.00
Credit: $37.50
Wanted: 15
Verdant Catacombs
Modern Horizons 2
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 14
Arcane Signet
Commander 2021
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Necroblossom Snarl
Strixhaven: School of Mages
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 14
Farseek
Time Spiral Remastered
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 8
Alrund's Epiphany
Kaldheim
Cash: $9.50
Credit: $11.88
Wanted: 16
Barkchannel Pathway // Tidechannel Pathway
Kaldheim
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 16
Blightstep Pathway // Searstep Pathway (Borderless)
Kaldheim
Cash: $7.50
Credit: $9.38
Wanted: 16
Darkbore Pathway // Slitherbore Pathway
Kaldheim
Cash: $8.00
Credit: $10.00
Wanted: 14
Goldspan Dragon
Kaldheim
Cash: $40.00
Credit: $50.00
Wanted: 15
Halvar, God of Battle // Sword of the Realms
Kaldheim
Cash: $11.00
Credit: $13.75
Wanted: 16
Hengegate Pathway // Mistgate Pathway (Borderless)
Kaldheim
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Hengegate Pathway // Mistgate Pathway
Kaldheim
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 16
Righteous Valkyrie
Kaldheim
Cash: $5.50
Credit: $6.88
Wanted: 15
Valki, God of Lies // Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor
Kaldheim
Cash: $16.50
Credit: $20.63
Wanted: 16
Sol Ring
Kaldheim Commander
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 15
Akroma's Will
Commander Legends
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Akroma, Vision of Ixidor
Commander Legends
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Apex Devastator
Commander Legends
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 14
Armored Skyhunter
Commander Legends
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Blasphemous Act
Commander Legends
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Command Beacon
Commander Legends
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 15
Court of Grace
Commander Legends
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Jeska's Will
Commander Legends
Cash: $18.00
Credit: $22.50
Wanted: 16
Keeper of the Accord
Commander Legends
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Kodama of the East Tree
Commander Legends
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Port Razer
Commander Legends
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 16
Sakashima of a Thousand Faces
Commander Legends
Cash: $20.00
Credit: $25.00
Wanted: 16
War Room
Commander Legends
Cash: $5.50
Credit: $6.88
Wanted: 16
Wheel of Misfortune
Commander Legends
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Agadeem's Awakening // Agadeem, the Undercrypt
Zendikar Rising
Cash: $15.00
Credit: $18.75
Wanted: 16
Clearwater Pathway // Murkwater Pathway (Borderless)
Zendikar Rising
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 14
Cragcrown Pathway // Timbercrown Pathway
Zendikar Rising
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Cragcrown Pathway // Timbercrown Pathway (Borderless)
Zendikar Rising
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 16
Emeria's Call // Emeria, Shattered Skyclave
Zendikar Rising
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Moraug, Fury of Akoum (Showcase)
Zendikar Rising
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 15
Omnath, Locus of Creation (Showcase)
Zendikar Rising
Cash: $9.50
Credit: $11.88
Wanted: 16
Scute Swarm (Showcase)
Zendikar Rising
Cash: $5.50
Credit: $6.88
Wanted: 15
Arcane Signet
Zendikar Rising Commander
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Blasphemous Act
Double Masters
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Isochron Scepter
Double Masters
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 16
Allosaurus Shepherd
Jumpstart
Cash: $70.00
Credit: $87.50
Wanted: 15
Branching Evolution
Jumpstart
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 16
Elder Gargaroth
Core Set 2021
Cash: $14.00
Credit: $17.50
Wanted: 15
Fabled Passage
Core Set 2021
Cash: $8.00
Credit: $10.00
Wanted: 15
Ugin, the Spirit Dragon
Core Set 2021
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 15
Reliquary Tower
Commander 2020
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Shared Animosity
Commander 2020
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 15
Skullclamp
Commander 2020
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 15
Indatha Triome (Showcase)
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 16
Ketria Triome (Showcase)
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths
Cash: $15.00
Credit: $18.75
Wanted: 16
Luminous Broodmoth
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 16
Rielle, the Everwise
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Savai Triome (Showcase)
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths
Cash: $11.00
Credit: $13.75
Wanted: 16
Savai Triome
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths
Cash: $9.50
Credit: $11.88
Wanted: 16
The Ozolith
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths
Cash: $14.50
Credit: $18.13
Wanted: 15
Klothys, God of Destiny (Showcase)
Theros Beyond Death
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 16
Nylea, Keen-Eyed
Theros Beyond Death
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 13
Thassa, Deep-Dwelling
Theros Beyond Death
Cash: $13.00
Credit: $16.25
Wanted: 13
Thassa's Oracle
Theros Beyond Death
Cash: $8.00
Credit: $10.00
Wanted: 15
Alhammarret's Archive
Mystery Booster
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 16
Coat of Arms
Mystery Booster
Cash: $16.00
Credit: $20.00
Wanted: 16
Gravecrawler
Mystery Booster
Cash: $12.50
Credit: $15.63
Wanted: 16
Vigor
Mystery Booster
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 16
Fabled Passage
Throne of Eldraine
Cash: $8.00
Credit: $10.00
Wanted: 11
Drakuseth, Maw of Flames
Core Set 2020
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 16
Finale of Devastation
War of the Spark
Cash: $35.00
Credit: $43.75
Wanted: 14
Spark Double
War of the Spark
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 14
Ancient Tomb
Ultimate Masters
Cash: $50.00
Credit: $62.50
Wanted: 16
Anger
Ultimate Masters
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Fauna Shaman
Ultimate Masters
Cash: $13.00
Credit: $16.25
Wanted: 16
Glen Elendra Archmage
Ultimate Masters
Cash: $9.50
Credit: $11.88
Wanted: 16
Life from the Loam
Ultimate Masters
Cash: $15.00
Credit: $18.75
Wanted: 16
Phyrexian Altar
Ultimate Masters
Cash: $70.00
Credit: $87.50
Wanted: 16
Watery Grave
Guilds of Ravnica
Cash: $12.50
Credit: $15.63
Wanted: 16
Resplendent Angel
Core Set 2019
Cash: $20.00
Credit: $25.00
Wanted: 16
Diabolic Intent
Battlebond
Cash: $30.00
Credit: $37.50
Wanted: 15
Luxury Suite
Battlebond
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 16
Morphic Pool
Battlebond
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 16
Seedborn Muse
Battlebond
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 15
Spire Garden
Battlebond
Cash: $17.50
Credit: $21.88
Wanted: 16
Stolen Strategy
Battlebond
Cash: $18.50
Credit: $23.13
Wanted: 16
Swords to Plowshares
Battlebond
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 14
Sol Ring
Commander Anthology Volume II
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Mox Amber
Dominaria
Cash: $30.00
Credit: $37.50
Wanted: 15
Bident of Thassa
Masters 25
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Eladamri's Call
Masters 25
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Red Elemental Blast
Masters 25
Cash: $5.50
Credit: $6.88
Wanted: 15
Rest in Peace
Masters 25
Cash: $8.00
Credit: $10.00
Wanted: 16
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben
Masters 25
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 16
Austere Command
Iconic Masters
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Primeval Titan
Iconic Masters
Cash: $9.50
Credit: $11.88
Wanted: 16
River of Tears
Iconic Masters
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 16
Search for Azcanta // Azcanta, the Sunken Ruin
Ixalan
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 13
Curse of Opulence
Commander 2017
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 16
Skullclamp
Commander 2017
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 16
Ramunap Excavator
Hour of Devastation
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 15
Razaketh, the Foulblooded
Hour of Devastation
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 16
Soul-Scar Mage
Amonkhet
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Abrupt Decay
Modern Masters 2017
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Arid Mesa
Modern Masters 2017
Cash: $19.50
Credit: $24.38
Wanted: 16
Inquisition of Kozilek
Modern Masters 2017
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 16
Verdant Catacombs
Modern Masters 2017
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 16
Indomitable Creativity
Aether Revolt
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Spire of Industry
Aether Revolt
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 12
Fellwar Stone
Commander 2016
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 15
Skullclamp
Commander 2016
Cash: $9.50
Credit: $11.88
Wanted: 16
Ghostly Prison
Conspiracy: Take the Crown
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Animate Dead
Eternal Masters
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 16
Ashnod's Altar
Eternal Masters
Cash: $14.50
Credit: $18.13
Wanted: 15
Gamble
Eternal Masters
Cash: $18.50
Credit: $23.13
Wanted: 16
Wasteland
Eternal Masters
Cash: $30.00
Credit: $37.50
Wanted: 16
Lightning Greaves
Commander 2015
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 14
Thought Vessel
Commander 2015
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger
Battle for Zendikar
Cash: $45.00
Credit: $56.25
Wanted: 16
Elemental Bond
Magic Origins
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Llanowar Wastes
Magic Origins
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Woodland Bellower
Magic Origins
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 16
Blinkmoth Nexus
Modern Masters 2015
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Dismember
Modern Masters 2015
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Lightning Bolt
Modern Masters 2015
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Clever Impersonator
Khans of Tarkir
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Chord of Calling
Magic 2015
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Llanowar Wastes
Magic 2015
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Swords to Plowshares
Conspiracy
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Athreos, God of Passage
Journey into Nyx
Cash: $9.50
Credit: $11.88
Wanted: 16
Dictate of Erebos
Journey into Nyx
Cash: $14.00
Credit: $17.50
Wanted: 15
Springleaf Drum
Born of the Gods
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Xenagos, God of Revels
Born of the Gods
Cash: $14.50
Credit: $18.13
Wanted: 16
Erebos, God of the Dead
Theros
Cash: $13.00
Credit: $16.25
Wanted: 16
Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx
Theros
Cash: $22.00
Credit: $27.50
Wanted: 16
Strionic Resonator
Magic 2014
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 16
Stomping Ground
Gatecrash
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 16
Watery Grave
Gatecrash
Cash: $14.50
Credit: $18.13
Wanted: 15
Blood Crypt
Return to Ravnica
Cash: $18.00
Credit: $22.50
Wanted: 16
Cyclonic Rift
Return to Ravnica
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 15
Deathrite Shaman
Return to Ravnica
Cash: $7.50
Credit: $9.38
Wanted: 10
Hallowed Fountain
Return to Ravnica
Cash: $8.00
Credit: $10.00
Wanted: 15
Pithing Needle
Return to Ravnica
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 13
Rest in Peace
Return to Ravnica
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 15
Dragonskull Summit
Magic 2013
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 15
Drowned Catacomb
Magic 2013
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Fervor
Magic 2013
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 14
Gilded Lotus
Magic 2013
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 14
Cathars' Crusade
Avacyn Restored
Cash: $5.50
Credit: $6.88
Wanted: 16
Curse of Misfortunes
Dark Ascension
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Gravecrawler
Dark Ascension
Cash: $14.00
Credit: $17.50
Wanted: 14
Huntmaster of the Fells // Ravager of the Fells
Dark Ascension
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 16
Animate Dead
Premium Deck Series: Graveborn
Cash: $5.50
Credit: $6.88
Wanted: 16
Kessig Wolf Run
Innistrad
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 15
Grand Abolisher
Magic 2012
Cash: $22.00
Credit: $27.50
Wanted: 16
Reverberate
Magic 2012
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 16
Sundial of the Infinite
Magic 2012
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 16
Sunpetal Grove
Magic 2012
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 16
Swiftfoot Boots
Magic 2012
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 15
Lightning Greaves
Commander 2011
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Praetor's Grasp
New Phyrexia
Cash: $16.00
Credit: $20.00
Wanted: 16
Torpor Orb
New Phyrexia
Cash: $19.50
Credit: $24.38
Wanted: 16
Triumph of the Hordes
New Phyrexia
Cash: $17.50
Credit: $21.88
Wanted: 16
Black Sun's Zenith
Mirrodin Besieged
Cash: $8.00
Credit: $10.00
Wanted: 15
Darksteel Plate
Mirrodin Besieged
Cash: $16.00
Credit: $20.00
Wanted: 15
Inkmoth Nexus
Mirrodin Besieged
Cash: $35.00
Credit: $43.75
Wanted: 15
Contagion Engine
Scars of Mirrodin
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 15
Etched Champion
Scars of Mirrodin
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Grafted Exoskeleton
Scars of Mirrodin
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 15
Memnite
Scars of Mirrodin
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 16
True Conviction
Scars of Mirrodin
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Whispersilk Cloak
Magic 2011
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Thada Adel, Acquisitor
Worldwake
Cash: $11.00
Credit: $13.75
Wanted: 14
Archive Trap
Zendikar
Cash: $30.00
Credit: $37.50
Wanted: 16
Arid Mesa
Zendikar
Cash: $35.00
Credit: $43.75
Wanted: 16
Bloodchief Ascension
Zendikar
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 16
Hedron Crab
Zendikar
Cash: $8.00
Credit: $10.00
Wanted: 16
Oracle of Mul Daya
Zendikar
Cash: $22.00
Credit: $27.50
Wanted: 16
Trailblazer's Boots
Zendikar
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Verdant Catacombs
Zendikar
Cash: $40.00
Credit: $50.00
Wanted: 16
Whispersilk Cloak
Magic 2010
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Ethersworn Canonist
Shards of Alara
Cash: $11.00
Credit: $13.75
Wanted: 16
Merrow Reejerey
Lorwyn
Cash: $7.50
Credit: $9.38
Wanted: 12
Thorn of Amethyst
Lorwyn
Cash: $25.00
Credit: $31.25
Wanted: 16
Snow-Covered Island
Coldsnap
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 15
Magewright's Stone
Dissension
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 16
Dimir Signet
Ravnica: City of Guilds
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 14
Freed from the Real
Saviors of Kamigawa
Cash: $4.50
Credit: $5.63
Wanted: 16
Ghostly Prison
Champions of Kamigawa
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 16
Skullclamp
Darksteel
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 16
Whispersilk Cloak
Darksteel
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 15
Isochron Scepter
Mirrodin
Cash: $10.50
Credit: $13.13
Wanted: 16
Lightning Greaves
Mirrodin
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Talisman of Dominance
Mirrodin
Cash: $5.50
Credit: $6.88
Wanted: 16
Talisman of Indulgence
Mirrodin
Cash: $3.50
Credit: $4.38
Wanted: 16
Talisman of Progress
Mirrodin
Cash: $11.50
Credit: $14.38
Wanted: 16
Brain Freeze
Scourge
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 12
Cabal Ritual
Torment
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Cephalid Coliseum
Odyssey
Cash: $9.00
Credit: $11.25
Wanted: 16
Rhystic Study
Prophecy
Cash: $35.00
Credit: $43.75
Wanted: 16
Mother of Runes
Urza's Legacy
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Priest of Titania
Urza's Saga
Cash: $9.50
Credit: $11.88
Wanted: 16
Turnabout
Urza's Saga
Cash: $7.50
Credit: $9.38
Wanted: 16
Counterspell
Tempest
Cash: $2.50
Credit: $3.13
Wanted: 16
Lotus Petal
Tempest
Cash: $16.50
Credit: $20.63
Wanted: 16
Goblin Recruiter
Visions
Cash: $6.00
Credit: $7.50
Wanted: 16
Mystical Tutor
Mirage
Cash: $20.00
Credit: $25.00
Wanted: 16
Lim-Dûl's Vault
Alliances
Cash: $7.00
Credit: $8.75
Wanted: 16
Ashnod's Altar
Chronicles
Cash: $11.00
Credit: $13.75
Wanted: 15
Mystic Remora
Ice Age
Cash: $14.00
Credit: $17.50
Wanted: 16
Animate Dead
Fourth Edition
Cash: $4.00
Credit: $5.00
Wanted: 16
Bident of Thassa
Theros Promos
Cash: $3.50